Pirate Point House and Compound
Sleeps 10
|5 Bedrooms
|5 Bathrooms
Rated 5.0 by 28 people
From $750/night
Message the owner — No booking fees.
Property Overview
About This Property
Guests tell us the photos don't do it justice. Pirate Point has to be felt to be believed.
Tucked away at the end of a peaceful canal street, Pirate Point is a private waterfront compound on nearly an acre of lush, landscaped grounds at the corner of the Avenue G canal and Coco Plum Bay in Marathon. A seawall runs along two sides of the property, opening up expansive views of the mangrove-lined bay. Tropical breezes, peaceful seclusion and an easy waterfront vibe make it a true Keys escape, just minutes from the beach.
THE COMPOUND
Three separate living spaces give families and groups the perfect mix of togetherness and privacy:
• 3-bedroom, 3-bath main home
• Separate 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartment
• Detached 1-bedroom suite with bath, just across the porch
Perfect for multi-generational families, couples traveling together, or friends seeking a high-end Keys escape.
BEDROOMS (5 BEDROOMS, 5 BATHS)
• 3 king bedrooms and 2 queen bedrooms
• Four of the five bedrooms have private en-suite bathrooms
• Purple mattresses on every bed, a detail guests consistently rave about
• Luxury linens and spa-grade towels throughout
OUTDOOR LIVING
• Sparkling private pool with poolside grill
• Dockside Tiki lounge, perfect for sunset cocktails
• Hammocks, sun decks and shaded patios
• Porch rockers for slow mornings
• Fish right from the long seawall
• Private dock plus a floating kayak dock for easy launching (bring or rent your own kayaks)
INSIDE THE HOME
• Covered entryway welcoming you into an open-concept great room with fully stocked kitchen, spacious dining area and cozy living room
• Den with large bar, game table and oversized lounge chairs with ottomans
• Coastal-chic interiors personally curated by an owner experienced in high-end interior design
DOG-FRIENDLY
Bring the whole family. Pirate Point welcomes dogs.
Pirate Point is part of the Happy in the Keys collection of luxury homes in Marathon, cared for by our family-owned team.
BOOKING NOTES
For stays longer than one week, special deposit and payment terms may apply. Please inquire about multi-week options.
Unique Benefits:
What makes Pirate Point truly stand out is its rare combination of privacy, space, and waterfront beauty — all wrapped in laid-back island luxury.
Tucked at the quiet end of a canal street, this property offers unmatched privacy and peace. With the home perched on a large corner lot surrounded by water on two sides, you're treated to expansive views of Coco Plum Bay and mangrove-lined canals — a constant connection to nature. Watch boats glide past from the windows and porches, or enjoy the soothing sway of palm trees from the hammocks at the corner of the grassy yard — a rare luxury in the Keys.
The outdoor space is a dream for both relaxation and recreation. There's plenty of decking and seating for sunbathing, dining, or sunset cocktails. The tiki hut with its cozy bench is a guest favorite — perfect for morning coffee, evening toasts, or watching dolphins and manatees pass by in the canal.
Families and groups love the thoughtful layout: large communal areas for gathering and celebration, plus quiet nooks where kids can play or adults can enjoy a moment of peace.
Fishing enthusiasts will love the extensive seawall — just grab a rod and cast off from your own backyard.
Pirate Point isn’t just a place to stay — it’s a destination. Whether you’re seeking fun-filled family adventures or peaceful tropical solitude, this home delivers a uniquely Florida Keys experience in every sense.
Host Story:
We first visited the Florida Keys in 2009 — and it was love at first sight. The vibrant blue waters, laid-back island charm, and natural beauty captured our hearts in a way no other place had. That one trip sparked a dream: to not only put down roots here, but to create something we could share with others.
That dream became HappyintheKeys — a family-owned lifestyle brand and boutique collection of carefully curated, upscale vacation homes. What started with one home quickly grew into a small portfolio of unique, luxury residences designed for travelers who want more than just a place to stay — they want an experience.
Each of our properties reflects the spirit of the Keys: relaxing, welcoming, and full of coastal character. We take pride in thoughtful design, top-tier amenities, and the kind of attention to detail that turns a trip into a treasured memory. From the moment guests arrive, we want them to feel at home — and like they’ve discovered a slice of paradise they’ll never forget.
We're deeply involved in every home and every guest experience. When you stay at one of our HappyintheKeys properties, you’re not just booking a vacation rental — you’re joining a community of guests who return year after year for the comfort, quality, and care we’re known for.
We’re so glad you found us — and we can’t wait to share the Keys with you.
Location:
Pirate Point is nestled in the private, upscale neighborhood of Coco Plum on Marathon island— the heart of the Florida Keys, perfectly positioned halfway between Miami and Key West. Located between Mile Markers 53 and 54, this quiet residential area is known for its peaceful canals, lush tropical feel, and proximity to the beach, boating, and waterfront dining.
The home sits on an extra-wide ocean-access canal at the corner of Coco Plum Bay, with water views on two sides of the property — including from the pool, dock, and expansive outdoor areas. Enjoy spectacular sunsets to the west and colorful sunrises to the southeast, all from your own private slice of paradise.
Whether you're heading out for a day on the water or simply soaking in the view, Pirate Point’s location offers both privacy and prime access to everything that makes the Keys magical.
Nearby Activities:
Fish, fish... and fish some more! 🎣 Whether you're casting off the seawall or heading out on a boat, Pirate Point is a paradise for anglers. During lobster season, grab your gear and go lobstering like a local.
Beyond the dock, the adventures continue:
Swimming, snorkeling, and scuba diving in crystal-clear waters
Kayaking and paddleboarding (rentals nearby)
Boating and exploring hidden coves and mangrove trails
Kitesurfing and watersports for the adventurous
Bike riding (rentals nearby) around the island
Golfing, pickle ball and tennis just minutes away
Beachcombing, sunset walks, and stargazing
Or just kick back... relax, nap in a hammock, and laugh with the people you love
At Pirate Point, every day is yours to enjoy — on land or sea.
Details
Check in4:00 PM
Check out9:30 AM
Pets?Allowed
No Booking Fees!Book directly with the hosts and save over 15% on your next vacation rental.
Amenities
Wheelchair Inaccessible
Area
Kitchen
Refrigerator
Stove
Oven
Availability & Rates
Available
Unavailable
Check-In Only
Check-Out Only
November 2026
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
November 2026
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
December 2026
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
26
27
28
29
30
31
January 2027
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
1
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
Additional Information
Contact the host to inquire about booking.
7 Night Minimum Stay
Nightly Rate: From $750
$600 Cleaning Fee
$150 Accidental Damage Protection - Owned properties only
Reviews
Loading reviews...

Managed by Happy in The Keys
We Put Our Heart & Souls Into Providing Our Guests With A Tr...
